For me, one of the scariest moments while watching a movie was during Evil Dead 2. It wasn’t one scene in particular, but I was watching with my brother and friend upstairs at my aunt and uncle’s house. It was dark and we were in a huge loft-like room. The bathroom was at the back of the room which was right next to a window with no window covering and a closet with no door. I was about 12 at the time and willing to wet my pants instead of go to the bathroom.
After some ridicule from my brother, I eventually made the trek to the bathroom, peed as fast as possible and ran back to the comfort of people. As I turned the corner, my friend jumped out and I jumped. Not up, but out. It felt like I was a long jumper at the Olympics. I swear I must have flown about 15 feet in the air. To this day, that movie still takes me back to that loft and that night and still creeps me out.